Purpose
To compare safety,
efficacy and long term stability between standard and augmented (with KIVA system) vertebroplasty in patients with extreme (split/incomplete burst or large osteonecrotic vertebral cavities) vertebral fractures.
Methods and materials
During the last 42 months,
we retrospectively compared 2 groups (15 patients each) suffering from painful extreme vertebral fracture treated with standard or augmented vertebroplasty.
Group A underwent standard vertebroplasty.
Group B underwent augmented vertebroplasty with implantation of a biocompatible peek cage (KIVA implant).
Standard x rays and CT scans were performed during follow-up.
Pain prior,
the morning after and at the last follow-up (average follow-up 12 months) were compared by means of a numeric visual scale (NVS) questionnaire.
Cement or implant migration were recorded....
Results
Group A: mean pain value of 8.86±0.99 prior and 2.27±3.35 NVS units post treatment,
with a mean decrease of 6.60±3.07 NVS units (p<0.001); progress of vertebral body damage,
widening of fracture line orPMMA migration,
subsequent vertebral fracture) in 3/15 patients (20%) with 2/15 being surgically operated (13.3%).
Group B: mean pain value of 8.73±1.03 prior and 1.40±1.40 NVS units post treatment,
with a mean decrease of 7.33±1.45 NVS units (p<0.001); no implant change or migration.
Pain reduction difference between two Groups was not statistically significant...
Conclusion
Both standard and augmented vertebroplasty seem to reduce pain in patients with extreme vertebral fractures.
Preliminary results show potential tendency for widening of fracture line orPMMA migration and subsequent vertebral fracture in the vertebroplasty Group.
In augmented vertebroplasty,
the implant seems to function as internal cast providing mechanical and structural support and height restoration.
Personal information
Maria Tsitskari MD,
PhD
Interventional Radiologist
2nd Radiololgy Dpt University General Hospital "ATTIKON"
Alexis Kelekis MD,
PhD,
MSc,
EBIR
Asc.
Professor of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
2nd Radiology Dpt,
University General Hospital "ATTIKON" Addr.: 1 Rimini str,
12462 Haidari/Athens,
Greece Tel.: +30 210 5831806 Fax: +30 2105326418
E mail:
[email protected]
References
Quraishi NA,
Elsayed S.
A traumatic,
high-energy and unstable fracture of the C5 vertebra managed with kyphoplasty: a previously unreported case.
Eur Spine J.
2011 Oct;20(10):1589-92.
Afzal S,
Akbar S,
Dhar SA.
Short segment pedicle screw instrumentation and augmentation vertebroplasty in lumbar burst fractures: an experience.
Eur Spine J.
2008 Mar;17(3):336-41.
Rahamimov N,
Mulla H,
Shani A,
Freiman S.
Percutaneous augmented instrumentation of unstable thoracolumbar burst fractures.
Eur Spine J.
2012 May;21(5):850-4.